Interventions & Complications

Search Our Site



JUser: :_load: Unable to load user with ID: 22097
JUser: :_load: Unable to load user with ID: 3789
JUser: :_load: Unable to load user with ID: 21994
JUser: :_load: Unable to load user with ID: 817

Fetal Monitoring - Is it Really Safer? Featured

Friday, 31 January 2014 10:06
Rate this item
(0 votes)

Beep. Beep. Beep. You are in labor, lying in bed attached to an electronic fetal heart monitor (EFM).  A medical professional enters the room and immediately walks over to this machine, and with no eye contact he or she unfolds the long strands of paper to read a foreign language that no one explained to you.  Nervously you peer down at your fingers as if you are getting graded. Beep. Beep. With that he or she responds,  “Okay, looking good. I will be back to check on you in a couple hours.”  Beep. Wait a minute. Did the professional check on you or the machine? That is where lines blur. Babies all over the world are being continuously monitored without clear evidence of the benefit.

EFM was enthusiastically introduced into the medical system during the 1960s and took off in the 1980s with hopes that continuously detecting a baby’s heart rate would ensure safety and lower the risk of perinatal death.  Ina May Gaskin explains that this, in turn, increased the rate of cesarean section because doctors had not expected that “the lowered fetal heart rates during uterine contractions that could be picked up for the first time with the continuous monitor...were absolutely normal” (116).  Many heart rate tracings are identified as abnormal when the baby is in no distress. Continuous EFM is highly sensitive and has the ability to identify fetuses that are distressed, but also has low specificity, or the ability to identify those that are not in distress. The EFM “therefore has a high false positive rate” (Walsh 60). 

Walsh conducted a systematic review involving 12 studies and 37,000 women comparing continuous EFM to intermittent auscultation (listening by hand with a fetoscope periodically after a contraction). This review found (58):

  • No differences between the two in perinatal death, Apgar scores, NICU admissions, or cerebral hypoxia (or lack of oxygen to the brain).
  • EFM halved neonatal seizures, but also resulted in a significant increase in cesarean sections and assisted vaginal births.

Evidence shows that intermittent listening with a fetoscope is just as reliable as EFM, and in most cases takes away much of the fear involved in birth resulting in fewer cesareans.  So why is this method still in practice? Continuously monitoring a woman in labor requires less human contact. One nurse is able to “monitor” several patients at a time from a local station. Doctors are able to monitor an entire unit. This in turn lowers costs and shows evidence, via the long strands of paper, that the baby was watched throughout labor if a courtroom was ever involved.

Beep. Beep. Beep. Imagine that you are back in that hospital room. Let’s say that your female nurse walks in and begins to document your baby’s heart rate. This time instead of looking down, look into her eyes and ask her to turn down that noise. Maybe even ask if she will turn the machine away from your line of vision so that it is no longer your concern, just hers.  Then ask her the best ways to move around. Most likely she will respond with compassion and understanding.

As a labor and delivery nurse I do this for all of my patients. I always offer to educate them regarding what we are monitoring, why we are monitoring and the policies that go along with that. Then I ask permission to tilt the machine away so that it is no longer a concern. Sometimes the mother and I even cover the machine with a blanket! I then show her how to move around the room while still being monitored, and encourage her to get out of bed if she does not have an epidural. 

Technology has a way of creating the illusion that we are progressing. This is not always true and there are data to prove it.  Hospital staff and even parents tend to depend on these machines, creating a mind-body split. Sometimes the monitor becomes more important than the internal experience. Don’t let that happen to you – keep yourself empowered and ask questions. The ancient ways of birthing through continuous human contact are still relevant and vital to health and safety for mothers and newborns.

For more information on this topic, pregnancy, or to read birth stories visit:

Gaskin, Ina May. Birth Matters a Midwife’s Manifesta. New York City. Seven Stories Press. 2011. Print. 

Walsh, Denis. Evidence and Skills for Normal Labour and Birth a Guide for Midwives. New York City. Routledge. 2012. Print


Read 3337 times Last modified on Thursday, 20 March 2014 03:55

As a labor and delivery nurse, I am passionate about the birthing process and have experience in both high-risk centers and home births. Each childbirth experience is unique, and I am always captivated by the birth stories I see unfold. 

I created the website Birth with Balance to give women a forum to share their birth stories, read the stories of others from around the globe, and learn more about the incredible, inspiring, and always personal phenomenon of childbirth. Birth with Balance is the only website available that focuses solely on birth stories, offers a questionnaire to help women write their story, changes to different languages and accepts stories in any language. It is a safe place for mothers to reflect, heal, teach, empower, role model, and offer alternative birthing options. 

Despite the billions of women who have given birth over the centuries, it often strikes me that so many of my patients enter the hospital without any real knowledge or idea of what to expect. Others check in to deliver with a specific plan for how they want childbirth to happen, and cling to this plan even when things do not unfold the way they had hoped.  

The handing down of birth stories helps women prepare for birth, reflect, and learn from one another. At their core, all women carry an ageless knowing of the divine feminine. This site was created to help women everywhere share their birth experiences and participate in the collaborative and cathartic power of storytelling. 

Birth with Balance is a safe place where you can express your experience without risk of judgment, and with the goal of building collective knowledge to empower expecting and experienced mothers around the world.

The intensity and harmony that accompanies childbirth is a place where both children and stories are born. I created Birth with Balance to tell each of these unique stories.

Please visit Birth with Balance.

Tell your birth story and read the stories of others!

— Chelsea Ann Wiley, MSN, RN, PHN

More in this category: The Truth of Cesareans »

Stay Notified

Keep up to date with changes and updates with newsletter via email . Contests, new articles and much more!